Only about 2% of Fidelity’s IRA customers do a Roth conversion in a given year, according to a MarketWatch report from November 7, 2026. Most of the advice aimed at that 2% is written for 64-year-olds staring down required minimum distributions. That leaves out the person who may have the cheapest Roth conversion window of anyone: the woman in her 30s or 40s whose income dropped this year because of a layoff, an unpaid stretch of parental leave, a sabbatical, or a year back in school. If that’s you, the window closes on December 31, and the right amount to convert is set by one number on the IRS bracket table, not by how much is sitting in your old 401(k).
A Roth conversion is a tax bill you choose the size of
A conversion moves money from a pre-tax account (a traditional IRA, or an old 401(k) you’ve rolled into one) into a Roth IRA. You pay ordinary income tax on the converted amount this year. After that, the money grows and comes out tax-free in retirement, as long as you follow the Roth rules.
The whole decision comes down to one comparison: the tax rate you pay on the conversion now versus the rate you’d pay on that same money when you withdraw it later. Nobody at 38 can tell you her tax rate at 70. But by late November you can estimate your 2026 income, and your 2026 rate, within a few hundred dollars. And in a down-income year it can be the lowest rate you’ll see for decades.
The calendar matters too. Unlike an IRA contribution, which you can make for 2026 until the April 2027 filing deadline, a conversion counts in the year it actually happens. A conversion that posts on January 2 is a 2027 conversion. It’s also permanent. IRS Publication 590-B states that a conversion made in tax years after 2017 “cannot be recharacterized,” so the old trick of undoing a conversion in the spring is gone. Do the math first, because there is no take-back.
The 12% bracket ceiling, not your account balance, sets the number
For 2026, the IRS inflation adjustments released in October 2025 set the standard deduction at $16,100 for single filers and $32,200 for married couples filing jointly. The 12% bracket runs up to $50,400 of taxable income for singles and $100,800 for couples. Above that, the 22% rate kicks in.
Add those together and you get the figure that matters. A single filer can have up to $66,500 of income ($50,400 plus the $16,100 deduction) and still pay no more than 12% on her last dollar. For a married couple the line sits at $133,000. In a normal salaried year, plenty of women blow past that line by April. In an off year, there may be tens of thousands of dollars of 12% space left empty, and once December 31 passes, that space is gone for good.
Worked example: the leave year versus the normal year
Say you normally earn $95,000 as a single filer. In 2026 you were laid off in May, took some time, and started a new job in October, so your W-2 income for the year comes to $38,000. You have $60,000 in a traditional IRA from rolling over your old 401(k).
Your taxable income is $38,000 minus the $16,100 standard deduction, or $21,900. The top of the 12% bracket is $50,400. Subtract $21,900 from $50,400 and you have $28,500 of room. Convert exactly $28,500 and the federal tax on it is 12% of $28,500, which comes to $3,420.
Now run the same conversion in a normal year. At $95,000 of salary, your taxable income is $78,900, already well inside the 22% bracket. The first $26,800 of the conversion fills the rest of that bracket (up to $105,700) at 22%, which is $5,896. The last $1,700 spills into the 24% bracket for another $408. Total: $6,304.
Same account, same $28,500, and the difference is $6,304 minus $3,420, or $2,884, just from picking the year. That’s before state income tax, which will add to both numbers, and before any growth: every dollar of future gains on that $28,500 is now tax-free too.
Notice what the example doesn’t do. It doesn’t convert all $60,000. The next $31,500 would be taxed at 22%, the same rate you’d likely pay in a normal working year, so there’s no discount on it. Convert to the ceiling, stop, and look at it again next year.
Who pays the tax decides whether this works at all
Your custodian will offer to withhold the tax from the conversion itself. If you’re under 59½, say no, because this is where a 12% conversion quietly becomes a 22% one.
Withheld tax never lands in the Roth. IRS rules treat it as a plain distribution from your IRA, and Publication 590-B is blunt that “a 10% additional tax generally applies if you withdraw or use IRA assets before you reach age 59½.” In the example above, withholding 12% would pull $3,420 out of the account. It’s already taxed as part of the conversion, and on top of that it costs a $342 penalty. Only $25,080 reaches the Roth instead of $28,500. Pay the $3,420 from savings, ideally by bumping up withholding at your new job or making a fourth-quarter estimated payment so you don’t get an underpayment penalty in April.
If paying the tax would mean draining your emergency fund in a year you just spent unemployed, skip the conversion or shrink it. Schwab’s guidance says the same thing: a conversion may not make sense if you can’t cover the taxes without tapping emergency money or other investments. A half-filled bracket beats a cash crunch in February.
Two other checks before you call your brokerage. First, if you’ve ever made nondeductible contributions to a traditional IRA (common if you tried a backdoor Roth), you’re supposed to track that basis on Form 8606, and it changes how much of any conversion is taxable. Pull your old returns before you pick a number. Second, if you’re buying health insurance on the marketplace during your gap, conversion income counts toward the income figure that sets your premium tax credit. We walked through how a small bump in income can wipe out a subsidy in our piece on the ACA subsidy cliff. In that situation, the cheap 12% conversion can turn expensive fast.
The 2027 brackets make waiting look smarter than it is
The IRS announced the 2027 numbers in early November. MarketWatch reports the standard deduction rises to $16,600 for singles and $33,200 for couples, and the 12% bracket stretches to roughly $52,000 of taxable income. That sounds like a reason to hold off until January. Mostly, it isn’t.
Inflation adjustments move the line by a couple thousand dollars. A return to full-time salary moves your income by tens of thousands. If your 2027 paycheck is back to normal, the extra bracket room disappears under it, and the $28,500 of 12% space you have this year shrinks to zero. The only person who should wait is someone whose low-income stretch continues well into 2027. If that’s you, split the conversion across both years and fill each bracket in turn.
Once the conversion is done, your regular saving can carry the Roth habit forward. Vanguard reports that 86% of the workplace plans it administers offered Roth features at the end of 2024. Once you’re back at work, you can split ongoing contributions between Roth and pre-tax (our Roth IRA vs 401(k) explainer covers how). The conversion is the one-time move that only works in a year like this one.
What to do before December 31
Pull your year-to-date pay stubs and any severance or unemployment statements, and estimate your total 2026 income. Subtract the standard deduction. Subtract that from $50,400 (or $100,800 if you file jointly). That’s your Roth conversion ceiling. Then shave a few thousand off as a cushion for interest, a December bonus, or a 1099 you forgot. Request the conversion early in December, choose no withholding, and set aside the tax from cash. If the numbers feel close or your situation is complicated, a one-hour session with a fee-only CPA costs less than the $2,884 gap in our example.
A layoff or a leave year costs you plenty. The unused slice of the 12% bracket is the one part of it you can still claim, but only until December 31.
This article is for information only and isn’t tax or investment advice. Talk to a tax professional about your situation.