How to Prevent Package Theft: Your $150 Doorbell Camera Costs More Than the Porch Pirates Do

Doorbell cameras film porch pirates but rarely stop them. How to prevent package theft this Cyber Week, and why a $149.98 camera guards $24.24 of real loss.

Woman receiving several delivery packages at her front door during the holiday shopping season

Three in 10 American adults have now had a package stolen at some point, according to Security.org’s 2026 Package Theft Report, up from 24% a year earlier. Cyber Week starts Friday, and the average adult expects 28 deliveries between October and December. So the question of how to prevent package theft is about to get very practical. The usual answer is a doorbell camera. I’d like to talk you out of that, or at least out of thinking it’s the thing protecting you.

A camera records the theft. It doesn’t stop it. What protects your money is where the box lands and how you paid for it, and both of those are decided at checkout, days before anyone walks up your steps.

The numbers say porch piracy is real but smaller than the ads imply

Start with the scale. Security.org surveyed 3,494 U.S. adults September 22 to 24, 2026, and found 4% had a package stolen in the previous three months. The average value of the most recently stolen package was $161, down from $222 in 2025. Location matters more than almost anything else: 10% of apartment dwellers lost a package in the last three months, against 3% of people in single-family homes.

Omnisend, which blended a March 2026 survey of 1,000 adults with FBI larceny data, put 2025 losses at $12.8 billion across roughly 228 million packages. Nearly half of thefts landed in November and December, with December alone at 27%. Spread across every household, Omnisend’s estimate works out to $101 a year.

Hold onto that $101. It’s the number the rest of this article hangs on.

Doorbell cameras make you feel safer without much evidence they make you safer

Ring has claimed in the past that its doorbells cut burglaries in test neighborhoods (50% in two Newark neighborhoods in 2018, for example). Those figures were never independently verified, and MIT Technology Review reported that Newark’s citywide burglary drop that year was bigger outside the Ring precincts than inside them.

The one peer-reviewed look at the question is less flattering. A 2022 MIT Media Lab paper by Dan Calacci, Jeffrey Shen and Alex Pentland, summarized by Undark, analyzed about 850,000 posts from Ring’s Neighbors app against Los Angeles crime data and found no significant correlation between posting rates and actual theft or burglary. Ben Stickle, a criminologist at Middle Tennessee State University who studies package theft, told Undark there is very little hard data either way.

Even Security.org, a security company with every reason to sell you hardware, offers no figure showing cameras prevent theft. Its report notes that 36% of people use a doorbell camera with AI alerts, and its own featured anecdote is a Maine case where the footage identified a suspect but the camera “did not prevent the package from being taken.”

The worked math: what a camera costs versus what you actually lose

Ring’s cheapest subscription, Ring Solo, runs $49.99 a year (or $4.99 a month) for one device and saves up to 180 days of video, which is the part you’d need if you ever wanted footage for a claim. The Ring Battery Doorbell lists at $99.99. Year one costs $99.99 plus $49.99, or $149.98. Every year after that costs $49.99.

Now the loss side. Omnisend found that about 62% of theft victims got a refund or free replacement, another 16% were offered store credit or a discount, and 24% got nothing back. If the average household loses $101 a year and you only eat the loss about 24% of the time, your expected out-of-pocket cost is $101 × 0.24, or $24.24 a year.

So the camera costs $149.98 in year one to guard against an expected unreimbursed loss of $24.24. That’s more than six times the money it’s protecting. Even if you ignore refunds entirely and assume you lose the full $101, the camera’s first year costs about 1.5 times that, and it still wouldn’t have stopped the theft.

Your numbers will differ. If you live in an apartment with a lobby-less entry, your odds are roughly three times a house’s. If you order a $400 espresso machine to the porch in December, one theft is worth more than a decade of Ring Solo. But that’s an argument for changing where the espresso machine goes, not for filming it leave.

The best way to prevent package theft is to choose the drop point at checkout

The most popular prevention step in Security.org’s survey was scheduling deliveries for when someone is home (43%). In-store pickup came in at 27%. Both cost nothing, and both work for the reason a camera doesn’t: there’s no box sitting unattended for a stranger to take.

For the next five weeks, I’d sort every order by value before clicking buy. Anything under about $25 can go to the porch; even in the bad case you’re out lunch money. Anything bigger goes somewhere with a lock. That means a carrier pickup point, a retailer’s locker, buy-online-pickup-in-store, or your office if your workplace allows it. If you’re shipping gifts to relatives, our holiday shipping deadlines guide shows why sending the order straight from the retailer usually beats boxing it yourself anyway.

One more filter: Omnisend found that 18% of past victims now shop only at retailers with easy refund policies. That’s a sensible rule to adopt before anything goes missing, especially since the “deal” price on a doorstep item from a stingy seller isn’t much of a deal if a theft means paying twice. Our breakdown of whether Black Friday deals are worth it covers how to judge the price itself.

How you pay is the insurance you already have

Most package theft advice stops at the porch, but the payment method matters just as much. If you paid with a credit card, federal law gives you a dispute right that doesn’t depend on the retailer’s mood.

Under the Fair Credit Billing Act’s rules in Regulation Z, a billing error includes a charge for property “not delivered to the consumer or the consumer’s designee as agreed” (12 CFR 1026.13). You have to get written notice to your card issuer within 60 days of the first statement showing the charge. The official commentary says you aren’t required to contact the merchant first, though in practice it helps to have the seller’s refusal in writing.

That right is not a guaranteed win. A tracking scan that says “delivered” will be part of the issuer’s investigation, and this rule covers credit cards only; a debit card dispute goes through your bank’s own process. But it’s real leverage, and it costs nothing. Practically, that means putting big-ticket holiday orders on a credit card you pay in full, screenshotting the tracking page the moment something goes missing, and filing with the seller the same day. If the seller refuses, file with the card issuer well inside the 60 days. Security.org’s data shows 60% of recent victims reported the theft to the store and 52% to the carrier, while only 23% went to police, so you’d be following the crowd on the first two steps and getting ahead of it on the third.

A camera is a doorbell, not an insurance policy

Skip the doorbell camera as theft insurance. If you want one for seeing who’s at the door, buy it for that, and be honest that the $49.99 a year is a convenience fee. To prevent package theft where it counts, send anything valuable to a locker, a store or your office, use a credit card so you keep your Regulation Z dispute rights, and favor sellers with real refund policies. The camera would have filmed the problem. These steps mean there’s nothing on the porch to film.